In Portugal’s second largest city, officials are banning new Airbnb units in busy areas, while allowing them in neglected neighbourhoods as the mayor argues they contribute to urban regeneration.
People in many cities around the world accuse Airbnb Inc. of driving up rents and contributing to a housing shortage as tourists take over homes once used by locals. Mayor Rui Moreira of Porto, Portugal’s second-largest city, sees how the growing short-term rental market can spur urban regeneration.
In areas that are already overburdened, the city is banning the creation of new short-term rentals – unless it’s an abandoned house. But there are areas where short-term rentals can be developed, Moreira said in an interview in his office at City Hall. Tourism can help revitalize cities, he said.
“Clearly there are some zones where more short-term rentals cannot be allowed and there are other zones where they can, and that’s a good thing,” he said. “When we think about Porto, for example, in Campanha, which is an area we want to renovate, we know that short-term leases have a very interesting effect because they accelerate renovation. And it is better to have a short-term lease on a house that has been renovated than to have a ruin in this area.”
“We want sustainable repeat tourists”
Portugal received more than ever from tourism last year, with revenues of 25 billion euros ($26.9 billion) in 2023, up from 21 billion euros the previous year, according to the government. Porto, with a population of 232,000, recorded a 22% increase in overnight stays to 5.9 million in 2023.
Moreira said some areas of his city are already “saturated” with tourists and that there are too many retailers selling cheap souvenirs aimed at them rather than local products. “Today we have shops in our cities selling souvenirs produced in China that have nothing to do with our handicrafts.”
Porto has adopted a strategy of “territorial dispersion”, offering tourists the opportunity to experience different areas of the city that are not the most traditional attractions, according to the mayor. “It has to be done through the carrot and not through the stick,” he said.
Porto wants to manage tourism in a way that creates sustainable repeat visitors, rather than one-and-done city hoppers who pop in and never return. “The repeat tourist is the best tourist we can have,” Moreira said. “And that’s where we need to focus our attention.”
Digital nomads instead of golden visa
In addition to tourists, Porto also attracts new foreign residents.
“We have more French people living in the city, more Americans living in the city,” he said. “There are families of young people settling in Porto and that has a very significant impact.”
Moreira said that in the last 10 years the number of IT jobs in Porto has quadrupled and employment will only increase with planned investments from companies such as bank Natixis SA and car manufacturer Volkswagen AG.
“We never sought to attract golden visas,” he said. “We’re not so much a retirement town. We’re much more a city of young nomads who come here to work for these companies.”
The prices of real estate
The demand for homes from these new foreign residents is “heating up” property prices, he said. House prices in Portugal continued to rise in 2022 and 2023, defying expectations that rising interest rates would reduce demand for property. In the last five years, house prices per square metre in Porto increased by 32%, according to property website Idealista.
“What we think is expensive is cheap for them.” A renovated two-bedroom apartment of 258 sq m on Santa Catarina Street in downtown Porto is listed at 480,000 euros on the property website Idealista. On the same website, two-bedroom apartments of around 200 sq m in the western part of the city, closer to the Atlantic, are priced at around 1 million euros.
Housing policy
Porto is investing around €76 million in housing in 2022-26, with policies including not only the construction of new housing but also the subletting of existing owner-occupied housing.
City Hall spotted an opportunity during the pandemic blockade in 2020, when small investors in short-term rental properties found that demand disappeared. Porto paid some landlords rent and then sublet their apartments at a lower, affordable price.
“This form of rent subsidy is much cheaper than building housing,” he said. “It has another big advantage, which is that we’re not uprooting people. It’s an anti-gentrification strategy.”
Around 300 houses are now in Porto’s affordable rent programme, some of which are owned by City Hall – not all of them are sublets. He expects the program to expand, with projects underway involving hundreds of new homes.
“There is no magic wand for the housing issue,” Moreira said. “The idea that it’s just the state and that the state will build housing doesn’t solve the problem. We have to find fair measures and different remedies.”
Increased revenues are directed to climate crisis resilience projects
Airbnb said in an email that since launching its operations in Portugal, it has worked with local authorities to promote sustainable travel, including working with City Hall to promote the Porto Seal Trust Seal and working with the municipalities of Porto and Lisbon to collect tourism taxes and redirect revenue to local needs.
The company “understands the challenges in the housing and tourism sector in Portugal and wants to be part of the solution,” the statement said. “We believe that the new EU regulation on short-term rentals offers a clearer and more proportionate way forward, which can unlock the benefits of hospitality for families and give governments the information they need to crack down on speculators and over-tourism.”
The Porto mayor said in an email that he aims to strengthen the partnership he has with the two largest booking platforms, Airbnb and Booking.com.
In addition to the challenge of providing affordable housing, Porto, like other cities, is facing the effects of climate change. The northern Portuguese city is located on the bank of the estuary of the Duro River on the Atlantic coastline.
“We are particularly concerned about times of high rainfall and this kind of disaster,” said Moreira. “Today, it rains fewer days a year, but when it rains, it rains a lot. We are implementing a policy at the level of gardens and parks in the city, whereby we turn them by design into retention basins into which we channel water. Park flooding has two effects: It doesn’t flood the homes of people nearby and it replenishes aquifers.”
Governments are also trying to reduce carbon emissions and, in addition to promoting the use of public transport to reduce congestion, Porto is encouraging more cycling and walking: For example, the city is widening sidewalks and connecting the lower and higher parts of the city with escalators. “In cities, walking is much more important than bicycles,” according to the mayor.
Moreira, who was born in Porto and previously worked in shipping and other businesses, is serving his third and final term as mayor and says the city is in “good” financial shape. When he arrived in 2013, it had a budget of €190 million and a debt of €100 million. He said he cut all taxes and the city now has a budget of 485 million with no debt.
Source: Bloomberg

