Property managers worldwide pay more than $1 billion per year in commissions to online travel agencies (OTAs) for bookings made by guests who have already stayed at the same property. This is one of the key findings of a new analysis by hostAI, highlighting a significant structural inefficiency within the short-term rental industry.
The study analyzed more than 230,000 bookings from 115 operators worldwide and concludes that the majority of repeat bookings continue to be made through platforms such as Airbnb, Vrbo and Booking.com, despite guests already being familiar with the property.
According to the findings, approximately 77% of revenue generated by repeat guests flows through OTAs, forcing property managers to pay commissions ranging from 12% to 20% for customers they have effectively already acquired. hostAI describes this phenomenon as “repeat guest leakage”, meaning the loss of loyal customer revenue to third-party platforms.
How many visitors are repeat guests?
Repeat guests account for between 1% and 26% of total booking revenue, with a median value of 5%. Operators with weak direct booking strategies experience the highest loss of repeat revenue to OTAs, while those that have invested in strong direct booking channels manage to significantly reduce commission costs.
The channel used for the first booking also plays a critical role. Approximately 86% of guests who initially booked directly returned via the same channel, while nearly 89% of those who first booked through Airbnb also made their repeat booking through the platform.
As Amirali Mohajer, CEO and founder of hostAI, explains, many operators are unaware of how many of their guests are repeat visitors, or why they continue to rely on OTAs for subsequent bookings.
The analysis also shows that larger operators lose a proportionally higher share of repeat revenue to platforms, while smaller operators often prove more effective at retaining and re-engaging loyal guests through direct channels.
The study is based on 231,150 confirmed bookings from 2025 and covers operators managing portfolios ranging from one to 588 properties.
Would you like to learn how to increase repeat guests at the properties you manage? At the Short Stay Athens Conference 2026, Daniela Derin, a successful property manager based in Marbella, Spain, with more than 23% repeat guests, will share her strategy in a workshop titled “How to Thrive with Repeat Bookings.”
Secure your spot now.


